Student senate asks Berkeley newspaper to apologize for cartoon
Paper was originally threatened with an $8,000-per-month hike in rent
© 2001 Student Press Law Center
October 15, 2001
CALIFORNIA -- In retaliation for a political cartoon
in The Daily Californian, the student newspaper
at the University of California Berkeley, the student senate
passed a bill calling for a front-page apology and sensitivity
training.
The legislation passed Oct. 10 with a vote of 11-7 with one
abstention. The bill was substantially different from its original
version, which stipulated an $8,000-per-month rent increase for
The Daily Californian. The bill that passed does
not mention any monetary repercussions for the paper.
"It took out all of the strong language to say basically
the [Associated Students of the University of California Berkeley]
wants to slap the Daily Cal on the wrist," said Daniel
Frankenstein, a senator who opposed the legislation. "It
doesn't do anything; it became something very symbolic."
The bill directly refers to a Sept. 18 editorial cartoon drawn
by syndicated cartoonist Darrin Bell that depicts two Muslims
in hell in reference to the Sept. 11 attacks.
"The cartoon may promote the kind of harmful stereotyping
that has led to the murder of Muslims, Sikhs, Hindus and Southeast
Asians across the country," the legislation states.
In the bill, the student government called for a printed front-page
apology for the drawing. The senators plan to request the apology
through a signed letter to the editorial board. They want the
paper to take responsibility for using poor judgment in printing
the editorial cartoon. The senators also are asking The Daily
Californian staff to attend sensitivity training.
The resolution concludes by affirming the First Amendment rights
of The Daily Californian. The senators proclaimed that
the paper has the right, "to express whatever views it wishes
and praise them for their strong editorial and news leadership
and service to the general student body during these troubled
times."
Prior to the revised bill passing, some senators, who opposed
the idea of condemning The Daily Californian, drafted another
bill. The "Free Speech for Campus Publications" legislation
proposes that any financial relationships, including funding and
space allocation should be "based on a content-neutral basis."
Proponents of the new bill believe it is still relevant even
though the proposed rent increases for The Daily Californian
were edited from the final version.
"When you have even the possibility of upping a rent simply
because of content, a precedent has been set that it is even a
debatable issue," said Frankenstein, a supporter of the bill.
Frankenstein said he believes the bill will be discussed on
the senate floor on Wednesday.