Teachers under scrutiny for commenting on attacks
Suspension overturned for Pittsburgh middle school substitute
© 2001 Student Press Law Center
September 26, 2001
Unpopular remarks about the Sept. 11 attacks have caused two
professors, one from New Mexico and the other from California,
to face punishment by their schools.
Richard Berthold, a tenured University of New Mexico history
professor, told a freshman class, "Anyone who can blow up
the Pentagon has my vote."
The statement, which he later apologized for saying, upset
students and caused state Rep. William Fuller, R-Albuquerque,
to suggest that the university fire Berthold. Berthold said that
any attempt to fire him would violate his freedom of speech.
"I was a jerk," he told The Santa Fe New Mexican.
"But the First Amendment protects my right to be a jerk."
University President William Gordon also reprimanded Berthold
for his remarks and is considering taking disciplinary action.
In Costa Mesa, Calif., a political science professor at Orange
Coast College has been placed on paid administrative leave after
four of his students filed a complaint about his choice of words
during a class discussion.
Ken Hearlson told the Los Angeles Times that he started
his lecture on Sept. 18 with an intentionally provocative question,
"Why do Muslims condemn the terrorist attacks in New York
and at the Pentagon but never denounce terrorist attacks in Israel?"
Four Muslim students took the opening comments and some other
remarks Hearlson made during the class discussion to mean that
he was calling them terrorists and murderers.
According to the Times, the students claim Hearlson
pointed to three Muslim students and said, "It was you who
flew the planes into the World Trade Center. You are a terrorist."
Hearlson admitted to making the comments but said they were
not aimed at the Muslim students. He also said he apologized twice
to his class.
The administration has hired an outside agency to handle the
investigation.
In another case, Pittsburgh Public Schools reinstated Rooney
Middle School substitute teacher John Gardner.
Gardner's suspension was lifted on Sept. 21, a day after he
was escorted by police off school grounds for having written the
remark "Osama bin Laden did us a favor" in the margin
of a newspaper. Gardner had jotted the quote he had heard on television
to remember it for a book he is working on titled "On the
Wings of Adversity."